Skip to content

research: X social discovery harvest run (candidate claims only, public URLs, date precision)#1

Open
ruemic wants to merge 10 commits into
mainfrom
research/hermes-x-insights
Open

research: X social discovery harvest run (candidate claims only, public URLs, date precision)#1
ruemic wants to merge 10 commits into
mainfrom
research/hermes-x-insights

Conversation

@ruemic

@ruemic ruemic commented Jun 24, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Public X/social discovery harvest only. This PR records candidate social signals for the watched Frontier projects without promoting any claim into findings, signals, digests, or profiles.

What changed:

  • Adds runs/2026-06-24-x-social-harvest-2026-06-24-frontier-v0/ with manifest.yml, harvest/*.md, verify/*.md, qa.md, research-journal.md, and social-cards/x-cards.yml.
  • Records 15 candidate harvest claims across 10 watchlist projects.
  • Adds 8 static social receipt cards for exact-dated X/social items. These render from repo data only, link to the source posts, and do not load Twitter/X embeds or scripts at runtime.
  • Adds a drama/code follow-up receipt map in verify/drama-code-followup.md so each GitHub release, PR, or official changelog receipt is tied to the exact bounded claim it supports.
  • Upgrades only narrow, source-backed social cards: Gemini Antigravity transition/migration support and Claude Code 2.1.187 release-note items. OpenHands ACP remains partial, Paperclip Maximizer remains maintainer intent, and OpenClaw/Hermes governance tension remains unverified social context.
  • Surfaces verify/*.md files in the run artifact list so the follow-up receipts are visible from the generated run page.
  • Adds docs/deep-social-research-loop.md and strengthens docs/x-social-harvest-workflow.md with the scout/critic/editor loop, receipt-to-claim mapping, reputational-claim firewall, and counterweight search rule.
  • Adds site/src/components/SocialReceiptCards.astro and run-page data plumbing so social cards appear on run pages as archived evidence cards.
  • Removes the loose unreceipted research/*-x-insights-2026-06-24.md narrative files from the original PR shape.

Boundaries:

  • This is discovery input only.
  • Product/version/capability claims still require source-contract cross-checks before promotion.
  • Drama/public-exchange cards are ecosystem context; they do not assign motives or verify governance claims.
  • Static cards receipt that a public post exists on a date. The claim inside the post remains unverified unless separately supported.
  • A secondary receipt upgrades only the exact bounded claim it proves; it cannot validate a different claim from the same project.
  • No local paths, session IDs, private prompts, raw private API payloads, or internal reviewer details are included.

Loop notes:

  • Hermes was used for X-native scout passes.
  • A skeptical critic pass rejected inferred-date, tracker-metric, self-referential, and overclaimed material.
  • A drama-specific follow-up found interesting social leads, but kept OpenClaw/Hermes governance tension, Gemini quota pain, and OpenClaw reliability complaints journal-only unless source receipts supported the exact claim.
  • Public code/release follow-up verified Gemini transition/migration affordances, Claude Code 2.1.187 release-note items, OpenHands ACP partial support, Paperclip OpenClaw/Hermes interoperability work, and OpenClaw reliability-fix counterweight.

Checks:

  • git diff --check
  • node site/scripts/check-integrity.mjs
  • npm --prefix site run check (0 errors; existing hint for an unused redirectChain local)
  • npm --prefix site run build
  • Rendered HTML sanity check for the run page showing upgraded cards and verify/*.md artifacts

ruemic added a commit that referenced this pull request Jun 24, 2026
- openhands, openclaw, pi-coding-agent, paperclip, agent-zero, flue, codex, claude-code, gemini-cli (hermes-agent already done in PR #1)

Each file contains maintainer signals, recent features, drama/community tension, and Bitter Frontier integration recommendations.

This completes the first full pass of the per-project X research loop.
@ruemic

ruemic commented Jun 24, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Updated PR with structured run per review feedback:

  • Replaced loose research/*-x-insights files with proper run under runs/2026-06-24-x-social-harvest-2026-06-24-frontier-v0/
  • Added manifest.yml, qa.md, and structured harvest/ files
  • Every claim now includes primary_url, author, observed_at, evidence_kind, channel, and status (candidate or single-source-unconfirmed)
  • Removed all editorial/promotion language
  • Discovery input only — no findings promoted
  • No trailing whitespace issues in new files

This directly addresses the evidence model, receipt, and artifact chain concerns.

ruemic added 4 commits June 24, 2026 14:37
…with OpenClaw, maintainer signals

First per-project deep X detective output.

Covers the new /learn self-improving skills system, animated pets, smart cron, 406+ community repos, public drama between Teknium and OpenClaw founder Peter Steinberg, Hermes #1 OpenRouter ranking, and integration recommendations for Bitter Frontier.

Part of the per-project X research loop for sheetgenius/frontier.
- openhands, openclaw, pi-coding-agent, paperclip, agent-zero, flue, codex, claude-code, gemini-cli (hermes-agent already done in PR #1)

Each file contains maintainer signals, recent features, drama/community tension, and Bitter Frontier integration recommendations.

This completes the first full pass of the per-project X research loop.
- Created proper run directory following feedback
- manifest.yml with sources, window, and verification status
- Structured harvest/ files with claim_id, primary_url, author, observed_at, evidence_kind, channel, status
- qa.md documenting limitations and checks
- All claims marked as candidate or single-source-unconfirmed
- No editorial language
- Discovery input only (not findings)

This replaces the previous loose research/*-x-insights files.
…st run with date_precision, reproducibility notes, public-only claims; update qa for discovery-only scope
@ruemic ruemic changed the title research(hermes-agent): deep X intelligence digest — /learn, OpenClaw rivalry, maintainer signals research: X social discovery harvest run (candidate claims only, public URLs, date precision) Jun 24, 2026
@ruemic ruemic force-pushed the research/hermes-x-insights branch from 191f972 to 383e031 Compare June 24, 2026 06:37
ruemic added 6 commits June 24, 2026 14:46
…rls; add verify/x-post-dates.md with per-cluster public resolution notes; update qa for crosscheck fields and discovery boundary; all claims now carry day-precision event_date or explicit reason
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant