diff --git a/docs/governance/OSOH_PUSH_DESCENT_EXIT_CRITERIA.md b/docs/governance/OSOH_PUSH_DESCENT_EXIT_CRITERIA.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..0325958 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/governance/OSOH_PUSH_DESCENT_EXIT_CRITERIA.md @@ -0,0 +1,27 @@ +# OSOH Push Descent Exit Criteria + +## Purpose +Define the exact Level 5 conditions that must be satisfied before the Sentinel push implementation descent may be considered constitutionally complete. + +## Exit Criteria + +### Criterion 1 — Externality Still Holds +Sentinel remains explicitly governed as an external monitored surface with no trusted-core inheritance. + +### Criterion 2 — Telemetry-Only Meaning Still Holds +Deployment and heartbeat senders are implemented only as telemetry producers and not as authority-bearing agents. + +### Criterion 3 — Credential Containment Still Holds +All push wiring uses an ingest-only credential with no broader privilege surface. + +### Criterion 4 — Activation Block Still Holds +Implementation of push senders and wiring does not activate Sentinel and does not weaken the future hybrid activation requirement. + +### Criterion 5 — Reviewable Evidence Path Exists +The resulting implementation can be reviewed to confirm that push evidence enters OSOH as bounded telemetry under fail-closed handling. + +### Criterion 6 — Return To Governance Is Possible +After implementation, the slice can be checked back against Level 5 invariants before any further descent. + +## Phase Completion Marker +This phase is complete when the push implementation descent has explicit constitutional exit criteria that preserve containment, non-activation, and reviewability. diff --git a/docs/governance/OSOH_PUSH_DESCENT_EXIT_CRITERIA_DONE_DEFINITION.md b/docs/governance/OSOH_PUSH_DESCENT_EXIT_CRITERIA_DONE_DEFINITION.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..cffde61 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/governance/OSOH_PUSH_DESCENT_EXIT_CRITERIA_DONE_DEFINITION.md @@ -0,0 +1,21 @@ +# OSOH Push Descent Exit Criteria — Done Definition + +## Done Definition + +### Condition 1 — Exit Criteria Are Explicit +The constitutional conditions for concluding the push implementation descent are fully written and stable. + +### Condition 2 — Non-Activation Remains Binding +The existence of senders, credentials, or wiring still cannot activate Sentinel by itself. + +### Condition 3 — Telemetry Containment Remains Binding +All implemented push behavior remains bounded to telemetry contribution only. + +### Condition 4 — Reviewability Remains Binding +The completed push slice remains reviewable against Level 5 invariants before any further expansion. + +### Condition 5 — Future Hybrid Requirement Remains Binding +The later hybrid pull-plus-push verification requirement remains untouched and mandatory. + +## Phase Completion Marker +This phase is complete when the push descent exit conditions are explicit, stable, non-activating, reviewable, and still subordinate to the future hybrid proof gate.