Follow-up from PR #1 interlock review. This is important safety-policy work, but it is not a Phase-0 merge blocker.
Problem
Current blocked() cooldown behavior only commands fan output when sensors_ok() is true, and sensors_ok() requires all required temperature sensors to be valid and finite.
That means a single failed sensor can suppress cooldown fan output even when another valid sensor still reports residual heat.
Example:
- chamber sensor: open/invalid
- outlet sensor: valid and hot
- case sensor: valid and hot
- heater: correctly blocked
- current fan policy: 0% because the aggregate sensor-valid condition fails
The safest behavior is not yet established. We should not casually invent a policy before considering airflow hardware, residual-heat behavior, reboot/brownout handling, and fault recovery.
Decision required
Define the product-level cooldown/fault policy for:
- one sensor invalid while another valid sensor indicates residual heat;
- all temperature sensors unavailable or implausible;
- sensor failure while actively heating;
- normal stop versus latched fault;
- reboot/brownout during cooldown;
- fan failure during required cooldown;
- minimum/maximum cooldown duration if temperature evidence is unavailable;
- recovery and fault-clear prerequisites.
Acceptance criteria
- Conservative cooldown behavior is explicitly documented.
- The policy distinguishes trustworthy remaining temperature evidence from complete sensor uncertainty.
- Interlock/fan behavior is updated if required.
- Host tests cover the chosen fault-state transitions.
- Bench/HIL tests demonstrate cooldown behavior on release-intent hardware.
- The safety verification record identifies retained evidence and its location.
Related: PR #1.
Follow-up from PR #1 interlock review. This is important safety-policy work, but it is not a Phase-0 merge blocker.
Problem
Current
blocked()cooldown behavior only commands fan output whensensors_ok()is true, andsensors_ok()requires all required temperature sensors to be valid and finite.That means a single failed sensor can suppress cooldown fan output even when another valid sensor still reports residual heat.
Example:
The safest behavior is not yet established. We should not casually invent a policy before considering airflow hardware, residual-heat behavior, reboot/brownout handling, and fault recovery.
Decision required
Define the product-level cooldown/fault policy for:
Acceptance criteria
Related: PR #1.