From 394138c46dd7f2702edee6e62d369bf1e035d212 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: "Abdulaziz M. Shehri" Date: Tue, 25 Aug 2026 12:24:44 +0300 Subject: [PATCH 1/4] docs(cf11): close canonical task ledger --- .../tasks.md | 19 +++++++++++++++++-- 1 file changed, 17 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/specs/011-cf-11-multi-version-package-graph/tasks.md b/specs/011-cf-11-multi-version-package-graph/tasks.md index 5002a78f..553e8caa 100644 --- a/specs/011-cf-11-multi-version-package-graph/tasks.md +++ b/specs/011-cf-11-multi-version-package-graph/tasks.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # CF-11 Tasks — Multi-Version Package Graph -Status: implementation, reviewer reconciliation, and implementation-head evidence complete; final documentation-head gates pending +Status: CLOSED_CANONICAL — PR #13 merged with exact-head gates green; the post-merge CF-10 six-state eligibility rerun completed on the canonical CF-11 foundation. - [x] T001 — Record CF-10 comprehensive eligibility evidence and freeze CF-10 as `BLOCKED_BY_FOUNDATION` without changing cases. - [x] T002 — Audit current resolver, lock schema, CLI locked-package selection, and terminology ambiguity boundaries. @@ -13,4 +13,19 @@ Status: implementation, reviewer reconciliation, and implementation-head evidenc - [x] T009 — Run Format, locked Clippy, full workspace tests, CF-08/CF-09 security gates, real FHIR smoke, and CF-06 oracle gates. - [x] T010 — Reconcile Codex, Qodo, CodeRabbit, and Greptile review truth on the implementation candidate; no substantive returned finding remains unresolved and unavailable/rate-limited reviewers are recorded without invented PASS. - [x] T011 — Write convergence truth with exact implementation head/run identities and real multi-version lock evidence; final documentation head must rerun all configured CF-11 gates. -- [ ] T012 — Merge only after final exact-head gates; then reconcile CF-10 and rerun the same frozen six-state eligibility sweep before semantic execution. +- [x] T012 — Merge only after final exact-head gates; then reconcile CF-10 and rerun the same frozen six-state eligibility sweep before semantic execution. + +## Canonical closeout evidence + +```text +PR: #13 +final candidate head: 0c2519202372e6d9d4f7da08fc23e6b012caff9d +merge commit: 5cb1a4c3445c0ebd86654cfb467a5e008e801c3e +final candidate tree: c81fa47a31a08a7d3bf6af849a76f166de9f73c7 +ci: 31889322720 SUCCESS +cf06-oracle: 31889322723 SUCCESS +cf11-multi-version-proof: 31889322717 SUCCESS +post-merge CF-10 package eligibility: 6 / 6 frozen package states attested +``` + +The later CF-10 production gate is separate from CF-11 foundation completion. CF-10 remains governed by its own CF-06 oracle contract and frozen-corpus evidence requirements. From e54c4c076805c0669d7128d057dc912d034714cf Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: "Abdulaziz M. Shehri" Date: Tue, 25 Aug 2026 12:25:11 +0300 Subject: [PATCH 2/4] docs(cf11): reconcile canonical convergence --- .../convergence.md | 58 ++++++++++++------- 1 file changed, 36 insertions(+), 22 deletions(-) diff --git a/specs/011-cf-11-multi-version-package-graph/convergence.md b/specs/011-cf-11-multi-version-package-graph/convergence.md index 608028bb..f048fa36 100644 --- a/specs/011-cf-11-multi-version-package-graph/convergence.md +++ b/specs/011-cf-11-multi-version-package-graph/convergence.md @@ -1,23 +1,43 @@ # CF-11 Convergence — Multi-Version Package Graph -Status: foundation behavior proven; reviewer findings reconciled; final convergence-head gates pending +Status: CLOSED_CANONICAL — PR #13 merged after exact-head convergence gates; the post-merge CF-10 six-state eligibility rerun completed on the canonical foundation. ## Decision ```text -CF-11_FOUNDATION_BEHAVIOR_PROVEN_PENDING_FINAL_EXACT_HEAD_GATES +CF11_CLOSED_CANONICAL ``` CF-11 corrects only the package-closure identity model. It does not reinterpret compatibility, policy, terminology, oracle, source attribution, or CF-10 corpus semantics. -## Canonical base and implementation identity +## Canonical closeout identity ```text repository: TheHalfMoon/commandF PR: #13 -base: main -canonical base: 4c72f4a21aca757fbdadd2fe34384b8d0c746b85 +base before merge: 4c72f4a21aca757fbdadd2fe34384b8d0c746b85 branch: fix/cf-11-multi-version-package-graph +final reviewed head: 0c2519202372e6d9d4f7da08fc23e6b012caff9d +final reviewed tree: c81fa47a31a08a7d3bf6af849a76f166de9f73c7 +canonical merge commit: 5cb1a4c3445c0ebd86654cfb467a5e008e801c3e +``` + +Final exact-head gates on `0c2519202372e6d9d4f7da08fc23e6b012caff9d`: + +```text +ci 31889322720 SUCCESS +cf06-oracle 31889322723 SUCCESS +cf11-multi-version-proof 31889322717 SUCCESS +CodeRabbit status SUCCESS / Review completed +``` + +Post-merge reconciliation then established that the same six frozen CF-10 package states are representable and attested on the canonical CF-11 foundation. This completed CF-11 T012. Any later CF-10 production block is separate and remains governed by the CF-06 oracle contract. + +## Implementation identity + +Earlier retained implementation/proof heads remain useful provenance: + +```text resolver implementation evidence head: 7411cebaa3052ccd71e83a916eb8d02e8269912c proof/reviewer-hardening evidence head: 744a64c7fcd84961aed9ce0417d443129f230541 ``` @@ -39,7 +59,7 @@ The byte-identical statement above is intentionally limited to deterministic syn ## Real frozen-state foundation proof -CF-10 remains frozen. CF-11 reused one of its previously ineligible states without replacing or cherry-picking the case: +CF-11 reused one previously ineligible frozen CF-10 state without replacing or cherry-picking the case: ```text state: C002-ips-after @@ -47,7 +67,7 @@ package: hl7.fhir.uv.ips@2.0.1 prior CF-10 failure: hl7.terminology.r4 selected 7.2.0, requested 7.1.0 ``` -Final proof/reviewer-hardening evidence on head `744a64c7fcd84961aed9ce0417d443129f230541`: +Proof/reviewer-hardening evidence on head `744a64c7fcd84961aed9ce0417d443129f230541`: ```text workflow: cf11-multi-version-proof @@ -64,7 +84,7 @@ roots (name, version, sha256, declared dependencies) ``` -Transport provenance is kept explicit for every locked package in both resolutions but is not used as a cross-run equality requirement. `LockedPackage.source` records the actual validated acquisition URL, which may legitimately differ if registry fallback or an accepted redirect is used. The final evidence artifact records both resolution package sets with exact `name`, `version`, `source`, `sha256`, and declared dependencies. In the observed final evidence run, `transport_provenance_identical` was also `true`, but that observation is not elevated into a convergence requirement. +Transport provenance is kept explicit for every locked package in both resolutions but is not used as a cross-run equality requirement. `LockedPackage.source` records the actual validated acquisition URL, which may legitimately differ if registry fallback or an accepted redirect is used. The retained evidence artifact records both resolution package sets with exact `name`, `version`, `source`, `sha256`, and declared dependencies. In the observed evidence run, `transport_provenance_identical` was also `true`, but that observation is not elevated into a convergence requirement. The same-name multi-version closure contained: @@ -88,7 +108,7 @@ cargo: cargo 1.97.1 (c980f4866 2026-06-30) The workflow also uses immutable action SHAs, `persist-credentials: false`, and path coverage for resolver, lock, cache, registry/source, CLI, Cargo inputs, CF-11 specs, donor metadata, and the proof workflow itself. -## Exact proof/reviewer-hardening regression gates +## Regression gates Head `744a64c7fcd84961aed9ce0417d443129f230541` passed: @@ -98,6 +118,8 @@ cf06-oracle 31858846042 SUCCESS cf11-multi-version-proof 31858847516 SUCCESS ``` +The final reviewed head later passed the canonical closeout gate set recorded above. + The mainline workflow passed Format, locked Clippy with `-D warnings`, full workspace tests, CF-08 and CF-09 security regressions, real FHIR resolve/verify + inspect/diff/classify/check, terminology smoke, CF-09 fixture preparation, local composite Action source-map self-check, and output verification. The dedicated oracle workflow passed the pinned HL7 adapter build, real R4 context, self-equivalence, `commandf oracle` self-diff, invalid-snapshot and corrupted-cache fail-closed gates, changed-profile determinism, and end-to-end reconciliation. @@ -110,9 +132,9 @@ Terminology canonical ambiguity and duplicate protections are unchanged. ## CF-10 boundary -CF-10 / PR #11 remains frozen and `BLOCKED_BY_FOUNDATION` until CF-11 is canonical. No CF-10 case may be replaced merely because the previous resolver rejected it. +The required post-merge foundation action was completed: PR #11 was reconciled onto the canonical CF-11 foundation and the same six frozen package states were rerun without replacing cases. All six package states are representable and attested. -After CF-11 becomes canonical, the first CF-10 action must be to reconcile onto the new main and rerun the exact same six frozen package states. Semantic diff/classify/check/terminology/oracle execution remains blocked until that eligibility rerun establishes the new foundation state. +That result closes CF-11 foundation work only. CF-10's later production gate remains independently blocked by the current CF-06 production oracle contract for C001/C002. CF-11 does not authorize changing that oracle identity or reinterpreting those failures. ## Reviewer truth and dispositions @@ -122,20 +144,12 @@ After CF-11 becomes canonical, the first CF-10 action must be to reconcile onto - **Greptile:** exact-head review was requested; no returned substantive result was observed. No PASS is claimed. - **Cubic:** generated PR summaries only; not treated as correctness certification. -Reviewer absence is recorded rather than replaced with invented approval. A new substantive reviewer finding after this convergence update reopens the merge gate. +Reviewer absence is recorded rather than replaced with invented approval. ## Research inputs explicitly outside CF-11 Recent research/donor inputs — CPGPrompt, PathWISE, and `reason-healthcare/rh-skills` — are not dependencies of this foundation correction and do not modify its acceptance criteria. They belong to later research/benchmark/clinical-knowledge roadmap work after the package/corpus foundation is stable. -## Final convergence-head rule - -This final convergence reconciliation changes documentation only. Its resulting repository head MUST pass all three configured CF-11 gates again: - -```text -ci -cf06-oracle -cf11-multi-version-proof -``` +## Closure rule -The final convergence-head SHA and final run ids are recorded in PR #13 metadata/body after those workflows settle. A failure or new substantive unresolved review thread reopens convergence. This document intentionally does not self-reference its own future commit SHA/run ids. +CF-11 is closed canonical because the final reviewed candidate passed all configured CF-11 gates, PR #13 merged, and the required post-merge same-six-state CF-10 eligibility rerun completed. Any future regression in exact package identity, deterministic semantic lock ordering, digest/provenance retention, or fail-closed name-only ambiguity reopens the relevant foundation behavior as a new issue rather than retroactively changing this closeout record. From 68b4b37d51bc04043e52d00b194f525e7fceae1d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: "Abdulaziz M. Shehri" Date: Wed, 26 Aug 2026 03:37:33 +0300 Subject: [PATCH 3/4] docs(cf11): bind six-state closeout evidence --- specs/011-cf-11-multi-version-package-graph/convergence.md | 6 ++++-- 1 file changed, 4 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/specs/011-cf-11-multi-version-package-graph/convergence.md b/specs/011-cf-11-multi-version-package-graph/convergence.md index f048fa36..4bbf4755 100644 --- a/specs/011-cf-11-multi-version-package-graph/convergence.md +++ b/specs/011-cf-11-multi-version-package-graph/convergence.md @@ -33,6 +33,8 @@ CodeRabbit status SUCCESS / Review completed Post-merge reconciliation then established that the same six frozen CF-10 package states are representable and attested on the canonical CF-11 foundation. This completed CF-11 T012. Any later CF-10 production block is separate and remains governed by the CF-06 oracle contract. +The durable six-state evidence is the retained CF-10 full-corpus reproof on PR #11 head `5fe10d9859407272acf6649fc3e868d3eb2fbd12`, whose base is canonical main `5cb1a4c3445c0ebd86654cfb467a5e008e801c3e` (the PR #13 merge commit). Run `31916124080` executed the unchanged C001/C002/C003 before+after corpus, retained exact closure evidence for all six package states, and uploaded artifact `9255732702` (`cf10-real-corpus-evidence`) with GitHub-recorded digest `sha256:9fdde985bb5abbe53ec2bce2dadc5f65c95557f8848c9af68755fc81a45af612`. The workflow's overall conclusion is `failure` only because the separately governed production CF-06 oracle still fails operationally for C001/C002; package-state representability, closure binding, and retained evidence completed before that final enforcement failure. Artifact expiry does not change the immutable GitHub-recorded run/head/digest identity. + ## Implementation identity Earlier retained implementation/proof heads remain useful provenance: @@ -132,7 +134,7 @@ Terminology canonical ambiguity and duplicate protections are unchanged. ## CF-10 boundary -The required post-merge foundation action was completed: PR #11 was reconciled onto the canonical CF-11 foundation and the same six frozen package states were rerun without replacing cases. All six package states are representable and attested. +The required post-merge foundation action was completed: PR #11 was reconciled onto the canonical CF-11 foundation and the same six frozen package states were rerun without replacing cases. All six package states are representable and attested by CF-10 run `31916124080` / artifact `9255732702` at digest `sha256:9fdde985bb5abbe53ec2bce2dadc5f65c95557f8848c9af68755fc81a45af612`, on PR #11 head `5fe10d9859407272acf6649fc3e868d3eb2fbd12` based on CF-11 merge commit `5cb1a4c3445c0ebd86654cfb467a5e008e801c3e`. That result closes CF-11 foundation work only. CF-10's later production gate remains independently blocked by the current CF-06 production oracle contract for C001/C002. CF-11 does not authorize changing that oracle identity or reinterpreting those failures. @@ -152,4 +154,4 @@ Recent research/donor inputs — CPGPrompt, PathWISE, and `reason-healthcare/rh- ## Closure rule -CF-11 is closed canonical because the final reviewed candidate passed all configured CF-11 gates, PR #13 merged, and the required post-merge same-six-state CF-10 eligibility rerun completed. Any future regression in exact package identity, deterministic semantic lock ordering, digest/provenance retention, or fail-closed name-only ambiguity reopens the relevant foundation behavior as a new issue rather than retroactively changing this closeout record. +CF-11 is closed canonical because the final reviewed candidate passed all configured CF-11 gates, PR #13 merged, and the required post-merge same-six-state CF-10 eligibility rerun completed with immutable run/head/artifact-digest identity recorded above. Any future regression in exact package identity, deterministic semantic lock ordering, digest/provenance retention, or fail-closed name-only ambiguity reopens the relevant foundation behavior as a new issue rather than retroactively changing this closeout record. From 9c37685b6e21322877dca94ba3be9a2ae625ff4c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: "Abdulaziz M. Shehri" Date: Wed, 26 Aug 2026 03:37:43 +0300 Subject: [PATCH 4/4] docs(cf11): record durable T012 evidence --- .../tasks.md | 18 +++++++++++++++--- 1 file changed, 15 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/specs/011-cf-11-multi-version-package-graph/tasks.md b/specs/011-cf-11-multi-version-package-graph/tasks.md index 553e8caa..cb933052 100644 --- a/specs/011-cf-11-multi-version-package-graph/tasks.md +++ b/specs/011-cf-11-multi-version-package-graph/tasks.md @@ -1,6 +1,6 @@ # CF-11 Tasks — Multi-Version Package Graph -Status: CLOSED_CANONICAL — PR #13 merged with exact-head gates green; the post-merge CF-10 six-state eligibility rerun completed on the canonical CF-11 foundation. +Status: CLOSED_CANONICAL — PR #13 merged with exact-head gates green; the post-merge CF-10 six-state eligibility rerun completed on the canonical CF-11 foundation with immutable run/head/artifact-digest identity recorded below. - [x] T001 — Record CF-10 comprehensive eligibility evidence and freeze CF-10 as `BLOCKED_BY_FOUNDATION` without changing cases. - [x] T002 — Audit current resolver, lock schema, CLI locked-package selection, and terminology ambiguity boundaries. @@ -13,7 +13,7 @@ Status: CLOSED_CANONICAL — PR #13 merged with exact-head gates green; the post - [x] T009 — Run Format, locked Clippy, full workspace tests, CF-08/CF-09 security gates, real FHIR smoke, and CF-06 oracle gates. - [x] T010 — Reconcile Codex, Qodo, CodeRabbit, and Greptile review truth on the implementation candidate; no substantive returned finding remains unresolved and unavailable/rate-limited reviewers are recorded without invented PASS. - [x] T011 — Write convergence truth with exact implementation head/run identities and real multi-version lock evidence; final documentation head must rerun all configured CF-11 gates. -- [x] T012 — Merge only after final exact-head gates; then reconcile CF-10 and rerun the same frozen six-state eligibility sweep before semantic execution. +- [x] T012 — Merge only after final exact-head gates; then reconcile CF-10 and rerun the same frozen six-state eligibility sweep before semantic execution. Completed by the retained CF-10 full-corpus reproof identified below; the later CF-06 production-oracle failure is a separate gate. ## Canonical closeout evidence @@ -25,7 +25,19 @@ final candidate tree: c81fa47a31a08a7d3bf6af849a76f166de9f73c7 ci: 31889322720 SUCCESS cf06-oracle: 31889322723 SUCCESS cf11-multi-version-proof: 31889322717 SUCCESS -post-merge CF-10 package eligibility: 6 / 6 frozen package states attested + +post-merge six-state evidence: +CF-10 PR: #11 +CF-10 evidence head: 5fe10d9859407272acf6649fc3e868d3eb2fbd12 +CF-10 base / CF-11 merge commit: 5cb1a4c3445c0ebd86654cfb467a5e008e801c3e +workflow: cf10-real-corpus +run: 31916124080 +unchanged package states: C001/C002/C003 before + after = 6 / 6 attested +artifact: cf10-real-corpus-evidence +artifact id: 9255732702 +artifact digest: sha256:9fdde985bb5abbe53ec2bce2dadc5f65c95557f8848c9af68755fc81a45af612 ``` +Run `31916124080` has an overall `failure` conclusion because final enforcement preserves the separately governed pinned CF-06 oracle failures for C001/C002. Before that final enforcement failure, the run completed the six package-state acquisition/closure evidence, deterministic A/B work, retained closure binding, repository-boundary verification, and evidence upload. The GitHub-recorded artifact is now expired, but its run/head/digest identity remains immutable evidence of the retained result. + The later CF-10 production gate is separate from CF-11 foundation completion. CF-10 remains governed by its own CF-06 oracle contract and frozen-corpus evidence requirements.