Skip to content

Docket: §1.7's comprehension gate is unrun in the ratified 4.2 for eleven constructs — future-edition material #75

Description

@dhh1128

Filed per round 42-6's reconciliation census, finding F-7. The census classifies the comprehension-gate seed wholly ORTHOGONAL: nothing in it conflicts with ratified bytes, and its eleven sentences are the only drafted discharge of a pass the ratified edition requires of itself.

The obligation. spec/custos-4.2.md §1.7 L410–437 is normative for the document itself and requires every construct introduced after Chapter 1 to be introduced as a named composition of the seven primitives, stated by the introducing section.

What the ratified edition carries. Gate-model composition sentences at exactly two sites: §18's GEL-event sentence at L3065 and §19's compact-form sentence at L3262.

What it does not carry. A composition sentence for any of: covenant (§5 L1195, now inside the law ladder), lens (L1229), organ and seat (L1234), availability charter (L1273), edict (§7 L1345), verification cone (L1350), warranty (L1394), anchor grade (§10 L2075), matched-anchor envelope (§13 L2328), computed congruence (§13 L2361), freezability (§15 L2767). Colored evidence is not owed one — R16 removed the form, which is what unblocked the pass.

Route. The ratified bytes are never edited, so the eleven sentences enter by a later edition or an erratum-grade successor artifact, per §1.7's own succession rule. They are drafted in PR #71, dispositioned merge-as-record, and are gate-model conformant. This issue is the docket entry that keeps them from being lost once that PR merges as a historical draft-of-record.

One of the eleven did not close cleanly and is filed separately as a ruling question rather than drafted around.

#37 stays open as the finding of record; this issue carries its statement against the ratified edition.

Relates to #37, PR #71.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    majorDoctrine loss or contradiction

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions